What Mask Filters Should We Sell?

As you probably know by now etee stands for everything touches everything else.  Our goal is for all our products to come from the earth and return to the earth, meaning biodegradable, eco-certified ingredients (non-toxic) and plastic-free.

Now that we're in the middle of a Global Pandemic, we are challenged with the desire to stay true to our mission, while also providing the protection people deserve.

You see, while Our FaceMasks fit perfectly with this mission - they are made with GOTS certified organic cotton and they are reusable - it is recommended to use a filter to ensure the masks provide maximum protection.

 

So we've been looking at filter options and the quickest to get in stock, cheapest and most tested is the disposable/single-use PM2.5 multi-layer, activated charcoal filter (with layers of synthetic melt-blown fabric), BUUUUT it's single use and it won't biodegrade any time soon.

Disposable/single-use PM2.5 set of 10 for $10.99. QUICK TO MARKET, SINGLE USE & NON-BIODEGRADABLE, PROVEN EFFECTIVE AGAINST VIRUSES

At the other end of the spectrum is a cotton filter that is more expensive, will take longer to bring to market and is not as proven. 

Reusable antibacterial cotton filter - set of 4 for $12.00USD. SLOW TO MARKET, BIODEGRADABLE, EXPENSIVE and unproven.

 

Another option that has been popping up in DIY circles is the Coffee filter.  It is - as yet - unproven, but it would be biodegradable and less expensive to produce.  

Disposable paper filter (coffee filter type) - set of 20 for $5.99. REASONABLE SPEED TO MARKET, BIODEGRADABLE, UNPROVEN

Soooo, with this in mind, we're feeling that in light of the Pandemic, it makes most sense to get the PM2.5 filter to market as quickly as possible while we continue to look into the more sustainable options; both from an 'ecological footprint' perspective AND from a functionality perspective.

We always LOVE to hear your perspectives though, and we read all of your comments and take everything you say into consideration, so....

Let us know your thoughts in the comments below!
 

← Older Post Newer Post →


Comments


  • I’m not interested in the disposable option or the coffee filter option (I can make that myself), and the reusable filter would be OK but I could make those myself too. Here is a story from NPR about nylon stockings repurposed as filters—surprisingly they work pretty well:
    https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2020/04/22/840146830/adding-a-nylon-stocking-layer-could-boost-protection-from-cloth-masks-study-find
    Might be an idea you could use.

    Mary Anglim on
  • Why do we need a filter to begin with? The mask is to protect others, not yourself. If you want to protect yourself you need a medical grade mask (mind it’s quite difficult to breathe wearing that one, especially if you’re active), you need to shield your eyes, and then follow strict protocols. How many people are actually going to do that?

    Arthur on
  • I have recently read an article about the most effective materials for mask air filtration in Business Insider – https://www.businessinsider.com/the-materials-that-filter-particles-best-in-homemade-masks-testing-2020-4

    This says that using blue shop towels as filters can improve filtration and provides a two mask patterns.

    Katie Mallady on
  • Filters are a balance of a few things, I think. Comfort is one thing because if you aren’t breathing comfortably, you are less likely to use the filter. The most effective filter is still only as effective as the fit of the mask which is relative in cotton masks and varies with face size and shape. Given that cloth masks will unlikely reach a filtration level of an N95 as there are no seals around the mask, I think the cotton filter is the most desirable combination of sustainability, reasonable protection, and comfort.

    Margaret on
  • Best to go with the proving when it comes to a breathing health issue. I would also look into vacuum cleaner bag material I have heard that that has close to an N 95 rating. I do not know if those are recyclable though.

    Peggy LovellFord on
  • I am not interested in something unproven. Pm2.5 has my vote.

    Patricia on
  • I vote for the biodegradable organic fiber filter or something sustainable. I have been making masks for family and friends. I have been making out of cotton fabric and lining them with silk. I got this tip from another mask maker. Fortunately, I have any vintage pieces for silk in my fabric larder. I also have many, many yards of 100% cotton fabric. For people making a quick trip to a known safe place I also make a few masks from Tee shirt type fabrics. I hope that information helps.

    Elizabeth G Tongue on
  • I have etee masks and also make my own. I use a layer of nonwoven fabric between the inner and outer cotton layers. I use Oly Fun fabric (https://www.fairfieldworld.com/using-olyfun-for-face-masks-what-you-need-to-know/). The manufacturer claims if you sew it in, it could eventually break down in the washer/dryer, but I sew mine in and have not had any problems. You can also use it as a removable filter, and it can be reused by cleaning it with Lysol or bleach between uses.

    Johannah on
  • I’m fairly indifferent. I have coffee filters and can easily cut them to fit. I’m not sure anyone would need to buy coffee filters from etee. Therefore, I’d say try selling the proven filters because there will be customers who really want them. Keep working on the reusable ones if you can because they might be popular if they are at all helpful. I agree with the point that masks are going to be leaky so the decision should take account of that (meaning a high-end filter might be wasted or might offset the leakiness). Another mod I’ve made is to staple a bendy metal coffee bag clasp onto the top of the mask to create a seal above my nose to prevent my glasses from fogging up. Have to remove staples before washing though.

    Royce Sherlock on
  • Definitely not vacuum Hepa filter bags. They are not safe to breathe through. I have not received my masks yet. Is there a filter pocket in them?

    Gerlinde on


Leave a comment