Is Silk the Right Material for Our Floss? Let's talk about it

The Canadian dental association recommends that we floss once a day to avoid tartar build up.

"In 1994, Americans used more than 2.5 million miles of dental floss, the equivalent of circling the earth more than 100 times." (Made how)

The problem for us - and our plastic-free mission - is that dental floss contains nylon and in some cases Teflon.  Nylon is petroleum based and we're not sure it ever decomposes because it's not found in nature and therefore microbes (those essential organisms that turn waste back into soil) do not 'eat it'.  Teflon - once the belle of the cookware ball - has similar challenges and there are also some potential health concerns.

Lastly, dental floss is typically housed in a plastic dispenser - also petroleum based and non-biodegradable.

After battling with a few different options we landed on 30 metre spools of 100% mulberry peace silk, housed in a glass dispenser with a stainless steel lid and floss cutter.  Sounds good right?  Well, some folks love it, but others may challenge our use of silk, with valid concerns.

So...why silk?

Well, in choosing our floss, we tested a number of options.  The bamboo floss we researched isn't typically plastic-free. Bamboo on its own isn't strong enough, so it’s typically laced with polyester; a step up from ordinary nylon floss, but not ideal because polyester is petroleum based and it doesn't decompose.

Corn floss sounded interesting, but our resident flossing geeks (we're looking at you, Michelle) came back with a resounding no when it broke apart super easily (as corn might), but it was so thick that it irritated their gums. Game over? Hold up, partner.

Then we tried some Ahimsa Mulberry Silk Floss. Great strength, decent thickness and lovely taste.

We finished it off with a glass jar to complete this plastic-free floss alternative. 

From a performance, biodegradability and style perspective it seems to have a hit the mark. Check out these comments:

"It's simple (refill packaging), elegant (the refillable container), sustainable, healthy, and makes a boring chore exciting!" (Elle M)

"It works really well. I’ve only used one type of synthetic floss that works better! I love this stuff." (Joseph C)"

"love it! It makes me enjoy flossing more. For me the best part is: it looks like a message in a glass bottle. So delicate!" (Rebecca Liu)

Silk's Dark Side

BUT, despite the good vibes, there is always a tradeoff to every decision a company makes - here's ours.

"How is replacing product with SILK and Beeswax more environmentally sound than plastic!!!

Aren't you supposed to be an ETHICAL COMPANY?

How is furthering the exploitation of animals better than plastic waste when there are options that are neither plastic nor barbaric?" 

Silk comes from a worm and the production of the silk typically results in the death of the silk worm.  It's a centuries old practice, but does that make it right?  AND, is it maybe time to alter that practice?

We searched for an option that avoided this nasty fate.

We landed on what is known as Ahimsa silk, also known as peace silk, which avoids the boiling of the silk worms in their pods. Although this 'sounds good', our next QC measure is to get detailed documentation that is more specific as to our supplier's process so that we can share a step by step with all of you!

We think we made the best choice with the options we had available, but we're always looking to improve and find even better alternatives - hemp being one of the suggestions.  What do you think?  What would you do if you were us? 

Curious as to what the fuss is all about?  Check out our floss here.

← Older Post Newer Post →


Comments


  • Ahimsa silk is a good idea, but I’m not sure it would work as floss because 1)It might be impossible to get a smooth strand, and 2) It would be pretty expensive since the processing it more involved . If you haven’t seen this article yet…https://www.seidentraum.biz/epages/64114803.sf/en_GB/?ObjectPath=/Shops/64114803/Categories/seidenstoffe/peace_silk/Infos_Ahimsaseide

    I do think that we should try not to compromise other beings as we make the painful but exciting journey towards changing the way we make use of our resources.

    Susan Goldman on
  • Glad you’re still searching for a viable alternative to silk. Hemp sounds good.

    C YOkem on
  • I boo’d at first because I assumed it wouldn’t be the non-lethal silk. I never floss; just brush well. My dentists always compliment me and relieved that they have a patient who actually flosses… lol. I may get this for my daughter, though.

    Jennifer on
  • I am vegan, so I cannot use your products that contain beeswax, silk, or any other animal product or byproduct since byproducts always involve animal exploitation and often death. I appreciate the vegan products that you do offer, like the dish soap I just ordered. Your plastic-free mission is excellent and admirable and I hope you will strive to become a vegan, cruelty-free company since non-vegan products harm the environment just as much as plastic does.

    Carrie Miller on
  • Bonjour, je sais qu’il existe un type de “soie” qui est présentement en développement au Québec et qui provient des soies de la plante nommée asclépiade. Je ne sais pas si vous avez fait des recherches en ce sens? Merci pour vos efforts! nous savons que rien n’est parfait et qu’il faut parfois faire le choix le moins néfaste dans ceux existants. Bonne chance dans vos recherches! Josée

    Josée Laberge on
  • I think the hemp iidea is intreaging. However, I suffered a bad stroke & must use those PLASTIC flossig aides. Every day i throw away a small piece of plastic plus the floss itself. So perhhaps you can add a (bamboo?) flosser? PLEASE.

    Lilian Weber on
  • I like the plan, I’m not vegan, but I wouldn’t use the silk floss. I would definitely try hemp floss though. Especially since there is more hemp farming going on, there may be more resources for it!

    Cristina on
  • I applaud your on-going efforts to find more environmentally sound options. I seek them out, too, which is how I found out about your company. I would love a non-animal-based, non-plastic floss alternative and hope you find one soon. I’m vegan, so I avoid consuming silk and beeswax. Hemp sounds like an interesting alternative; it is strong.

    Lucy on
  • Thank you for this discussion.
    A healthy discussion of all options will allow consumers to choose products that align with their personal goals.
    We are in a place of transition as we move away from plastics.
    I applaud you for being thoughtful and transparent in your decision making.

    LIanna Percy on
  • I guess if you come at this from a Vegan-oriented ethics perspective, then the silk would be highly offensive. I, however, do not see this as a black and white case. For me, the idea is that we are on a conscientious and honest journey to improve. There will huge steps, small steps and stumbling steps. I think that silk and beeswax is a vast improvement over plastic, nylon and polyester. I think hemp might be the next step in this evolving conversation. I also think we need to support each other and listen to each other so that improvements are reached more rapidly and more authentically. Thank you for posing these questions. I’m damned impressed. (She whispers: I responded and I can’t even force myself to floss.)

    Ann Tomer on

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4

Leave a comment